HMRC and £43 billion payout – is this correct?

/ Posted By - Bradleys Accountants / Categories - Accounting news

A £43 billion payout by HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) doesn’t sound realistic, and it probably won’t happen. However, as a precaution this is the amount they have stated in a worst case scenario.

It’s been reported that multiple companies are presently jammed in litigation with HMRC in regards to money that is owed. These firms are in disagreement with HMRC in relation to overpaid taxes ranging over numerous years.

The sum of £43 billion that HMRC has arrived at is actually a very safe estimation in order to account for a full blown loss. This outcome is highly doubtful; however, HMRC does not want to take any chances.

    Subscribe to our newsletter

    Chas Roy-Chowdhury, Head of Taxation at Association of Chartered Certified Accountants, had this to say in regards to the issue, “This is the absolute worst-case scenario for payouts but, as HMRC takes an increasingly aggressive stance on tax collection, it could find itself facing growing numbers of legal challenges – and paying out more refunds.”

    HMRC has actually stated that if it were to lose, a more realistic refund would be closer to the amount of £7.2bn. Out of the total amount HMRC has set aside, the remaining £35.6bn as ‘contingent liabilities’ where a refund is possible rather than likely.

    An HMRC spokesman said: “We are required for accounting purposes to include an estimated contingent liability figure of potential repayments of tax.

    “There is no question of this amount or anything close to this amount ever being repaid as the figure is based on our losing every single case currently being litigated, which is not going to happen.”

    With HMRC stating a win rate of 80% of litigation cases they are fairly confident that any refunds that do occur will be very minimal.

    Related Articles

    UK Spring Budget 2023: Top things to…
    | Accounting news

    On 15 March 2023, Chancellor Jeremy Hunt started his Spring Budget speech by informing Members … Read more

    Everything you need to know about moving…
    | Accounting news

    Ever since HMRC announced basis period reforms, there has been much discussion and confusion around … Read more

    What does the Spring Statement 2022 mean…
    | Accounting news

    Rishi Sunak tinkered with a few items in his most recent Spring Statement on March … Read more


    Subscribe to the newsletter

    Know about latest accountancy updates, company news and business growth tips. Every month, in your inbox

      Subscribe to our newsletter